Craftsman Riding Mowers: Are They Worth Upgrading?

When considering upgrading your lawn mower, it's essential to evaluate the current options available. Many homeowners are exploring whether the newer Craftsman riding mowers are worth the investment, given a 12-year-old one is still performing well. This article addresses myths and common concerns about Craftsman mowers and recommends alternative brands for those looking to make an informed decision.

The Quality of New Craftsman Riding Mowers

Time and again, there are discussions and debates about the durability and quality of brand new Craftsman riding mowers. Some owners, like a user whose new mower broke down four times, argue that the newer models are of inferior quality. They point out issues such as thinner metal and cheaper components, referencing a 2023 model that had to be taken to the repair shop multiple times, necessitating the replacement of the starter, switch, and carburetor. This user argued that the mowers are 'junk,' banging the red top cover that no longer uses steel, but plastic.

Given my background in understanding machinery, I can confirm that the assertion that ‘Craftsman’ is now just a placeholder brand name is valid. The decline in quality can be attributed to the outsourcing of manufacturing, which has led to a drop in the overall product quality.

Alternatives to Craftsman Riding Mowers

While considering your investment in a new riding mower, it's crucial to explore other brands that can deliver superior performance and longevity. One of the most highly recommended alternatives is the John Deere tractor. These tractors not only offer impressive performance but are also built to last. For instance, a 1990s John Deere LX176, which is a 14 HP, 38-inch deck, and hydrostatic drive system, is a testament to the longevity and performance of John Deere products.

Another recommendation is purchasing a used John Deere tractor with hydrostatic foot pedal drive. These tractors cut grass effectively and are known to last a long time. Additionally, the hydrostatic drive ensures smooth operation and better maneuverability, making cutting your lawn a stress-free activity.

John Deere tractors, unlike the majority of offerings from big-box home stores, are manufactured by the brand itself. This means they have the highest quality standards and are built to last. Comparatively, much of what you find in big-box stores, such as the Craftsman line, is produced by MTD (MTD brands including Craftsman, Snapper, and others) and is generally of lower quality.

Buying Used v.s. New

While new riding mowers like Craftsman are often promoted as higher quality, buying a used John Deere or other high-quality alternative can save you money and provide comparable performance. For example, a 1990s John Deere LX176 is a great option that is 15 years old and still in good condition. It’s priced affordably compared to a new John Deere tractor, making it an excellent value proposition.

When evaluating the cost, consider not just the initial price but also the total cost of ownership, which includes maintenance and potential repairs over time. This comprehensive approach will help you determine if the cheaper initial cost of a newer Craftsman mower is worth the long-term hassle and financial burden.

In Conclusion

Whether you should upgrade to a new Craftsman riding mower or choose an alternative like a used John Deere, your decision should be based on thorough research and the expectation of long-term value. If you are satisfied with your current mower and can find replacement parts, there's no rush to upgrade. However, if you're looking for a reliable and long-lasting option, consider alternatives like a used John Deere tractor for its superior performance and durability.

Key Takeaways:

Consider the quality of newer Craftsman mowers, which can be thinner and poorly made. Explore used John Deere tractors for long-term value and reliability. Evaluate the total cost of ownership, not just the initial price.