Is Israel Eligible for Joining the British Commonwealth?

The question of whether Israel could ever become a part of the British Commonwealth is an intriguing and complex one. This article delves into the historical context, the current status of the British Commonwealth, and the potential challenges and opportunities if such a recruitment were to occur.

A Historical Perspective

The State of Israel developed out of what was initially a British protectorate of Palestine. Like many other nations that once formed part of the British Empire, Israel adopted several civic institutions that have their roots in British governance. These include economic and political competition, the rationalism and empiricism of the scientific method, industrialized society, the 'Protestant' work ethic, and the rule of law based on private property rights. These shared values create a significant common ground between Israel and fellow Commonwealth nations in terms of economic structure, international law, and civil liberties.

However, Israel is not the only nation that once belonged to the British Empire but is not part of the Commonwealth. Other countries like Egypt, the United States, Sudan, and the United Arab Emirates might theoretically join if they meet the necessary criteria, which include freedom of trade, adherence to civil liberties, and anti-militaristic stances. Despite these opportunities, the current Queen has shown no inclination to actively recruit any nation to join the Commonwealth. The idea of Prince Charles actively seeking to bring Israel into the Commonwealth is also highly unlikely, as it would likely be a politically divisive move in the Middle East, especially given the lack of compliance with equality standards by some of Britain's other former protectorates in the region.

The prospect of Israel joining the Commonwealth remains a distant possibility, at least until such a time as Israel expresses its interest in doing so. To date, Israel has shown no interest in joining the Commonwealth.

Taras Zuk's Analysis

In his articles, Taras Zuk presents an alternative view, arguing that the British Commonwealth no longer exists as such. Today, nations apply to join the Commonwealth of Nations rather than being recruited. The land that is now Israel was not part of the British Empire/Commonwealth. During World War II, Britain made a significant promise to the Jews in what is known as the Balfour Declaration, promising them a homeland in Palestine in return for their help against the Ottomans. However, the land of Palestine became a protectorate with the aim of developing into a Jewish state. The British later reneged on their promise and took extensive steps to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state. Despite these complex historical facts, the current situation of the Commonwealth and its membership criteria provide a framework for potential future discussions on Israel's eligibility.

Conclusion

The possibility of Israel joining the British Commonwealth is a topic of significant historical and current interest. While the shared values between Israel and many Commonwealth nations suggest a potential fit, the current political climate and the lack of expressed interest from Israel itself make the notion of actual recruitment highly improbable. The future of the Commonwealth, as it stands today, is a dynamic and evolving institution, with its membership criteria continually adapting to reflect contemporary global challenges and opportunities.