Is Resubmission to Publishers Possible for Previously Published Manuscripts?

Is Resubmission to Publishers Possible for Previously Published Manuscripts?

Understanding Traditionally Published Manuscripts

In the world of publishing, a manuscript that has been traditionally published refers to a book that has been through a formal process with a publishing company, resulting in printed copies available to the general public. This can include hardcovers, softcovers, e-books, audiobooks, and other media formats.

Why Publishers Rejected Previously Published Manuscripts

When a publisher decides to reject a manuscript that has already been traditionally published, it is often due to legal and ethical concerns, specifically copyright violations. Publishing a book multiple times without proper permission or acknowledging the original copyright can lead to legal issues. Copyright laws typically grant the original publisher exclusive rights to the book, including the right to distribute and reproduce it. Resubmitting such a manuscript can be seen as an infringement on these rights.

The Risks of Resubmission and Their Consequences

Even if an author makes substantial changes to the storyline, dialogue, and characters after the first publication, attempting to resubmit the manuscript can still be risky. These changes might not be enough to avoid legal action, especially if the changes are minor or the publisher still holds significant creative rights. Additionally, the author's reputation could suffer. Publishers and industry professionals may view the author as unreliable or inherently in violation of intellectual property laws.

Can Authors Resubmit Their Work?

Typically, if a manuscript has already been traditionally published, authors should not resubmit it. However, there are rare exceptions where the original publisher has granted permission or where the legal situation has changed. In such cases, the author could explore re-negotiating rights, obtaining a copyright release, or seeking a new publisher who is willing to work under the correct legal framework.

What to Do if Your Manuscript Was Traditionally Published

If you find yourself in this situation, consider these steps:

Consult Legal Advice: Speak with a copyright lawyer to understand your rights and the legal implications of resubmission. Negotiate Rights: Attempt to negotiate with the original publisher for the right to resubmit your manuscript. This may involve buying back rights or obtaining a release. Write a New Manuscript: If negotiation fails, consider writing a new, original manuscript that does not infringe on any rights. Publish Through Self-Publishing: If you cannot find a traditional publisher, consider self-publishing through platforms like Amazon, KDP, or Createspace.

Guidance for Authors: Writing a Sequel or New Manuscript

For authors who wish to build on their previously published work, there are ways to do so without violating copyright. Here are some options:

Write a Sequel: If the original publisher allows it, write a sequel that continues the story in a new way. Make sure to include language in your contract or a verbal agreement with the original publisher for permission to do this. Create a Prequel or Side Story: Develop a narrative that foreshadows or expands on elements from the original story, but stays within the bounds of copyright. Write a New Manuscript: Develop an entirely new storyline that is completely original and unrelated to the first book.

Conclusion

The publishing industry is governed by strict copyright laws, and resubmitting a previously published manuscript can lead to legal and reputational risks. If you find yourself in this situation, it's important to seek legal advice and explore all possible options. While resubmission may not be possible, there are still ways to continue your narrative journey without offending copyright holders.