Joining the IDF as an Ex-Converter: The Path from Open Online Programs to Israel

Is it possible to join the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) if you're an ex-convert who has undergone an online Jewish learning and conversion program? The answer, as with many things, isn't always straightforward. Here’s a guide to help you navigate this complex journey.

Eligibility and Citizenship

Firstly, it’s important to understand that eligibility to join the IDF is often closely tied with citizenship or the clear intent to become a citizen. Israel does not discriminate based on religion but rather on the basis of military service obligations for its citizens. As a South African citizen and an Australian permanent resident, your next step would be to consider obtaining Israeli citizenship, which is a prerequisite for serving in the IDF.

There are ways to obtain Israeli citizenship, usually through the Law of Return, which allows Jews to immigrate to Israel. However, conversion must be recognized by a recognized religious body in Israel. Simply participating in an online program, even one led by prominent figures like Rabbi Marc Rubinstein, may not be sufficient. The Israeli authorities will require documentation and validation from an approved religious court.

Rabbi Marc Rubinstein's Program: A Closer Look

Rabbi Marc Rubinstein runs an online Jewish learning and conversion program. The program's claim that conversion is “easy as 1–2–3” warrants skepticism. Conversion to Judaism is a serious and often complex process that involves not just religious instruction but also a profound understanding and commitment to the faith.

When evaluating Rabbi Rubinstein's credentials, it's essential to consider the traditional context. His specialization in interfaith marriage and the fact that he received his education from the Academy for Jewish Religion (which is accredited by the New York Board of Regents but not by traditional yeshivas or Israeli accrediting authorities) might make it difficult to have your conversion recognized in Israel. These factors suggest that the program may not align with traditional Jewish standards for conversion.

Alternatives and Traditional Pathways

For those seriously considering full conversion, traditional pathways are often more reliable. Finding a respected rabbi in a major Jewish community, such as Sydney or Melbourne, is the first step. A local rabbi can assess your commitment and religious knowledge, guiding you through the necessary steps to pursue full conversion.

In Sydney or Melbourne, you might approach an Orthodox synagogue or religious school (shul) to express your desire to convert. Local rabbis will provide guidance and may require you to take part in extensive study and prepare for a “siyum” (commemorative ceremony) and a bat/bar mitzvah-style celebration, marking your commitment to the Jewish faith.

Conversion by a recognized religious court in Israel can take approximately a year, involving detailed study, a readiness assessment, and adherence to Jewish law and traditions. This process ensures that you are fully prepared both religiously and culturally to join the Jewish community.

Conclusion: Commitment and Traditions

The path to joining the IDF as an ex-convert is multifaceted and requires a genuine commitment to Judaism. While online programs can be a useful starting point to gain religious knowledge, they should be followed with a traditional pathway to ensure recognition and acceptance by the Israeli authorities.

Consider the following:

Secure Israeli citizenship: Through the Law of Return or a recognized conversion process. Find a respected rabbi: In major Jewish communities to guide you through the process. Complete extensive study and prepare: Commit to the necessary religious and cultural practices. Be patient: The process can take about a year to complete fully.

Ultimately, your genuine desire and commitment to Judaism and the Jewish community will play a crucial role in your journey, not just to the IDF but also to Israeli citizenship.

Should you have any questions or doubts, consulting with a legal advisor or a recognized religious authority can provide further guidance and clarity.