Jon Snow and the Legitimization Debate in Westeros

With Jon Snow being sworn in as King in the North, a question arises regarding his legitimacy and the titles he may (or may not) choose to adopt. This article explores the possibilities and implications of Jon Snow's potential legitimization, touching on his current status as a bastard, his complex lineage, and the various paths he could take to secure his claim as the true Stark and Targaryen.

The Current Status of Jon Snow

Despite being declared King in the North, Jon Snow remains a bastard. This designation has historically undermined a bastard's ability to inherit lands and titles. However, in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire, Jon Snow's charisma and leadership have made him a formidable and respected leader. He has been granted titles such as Lord Commander, King Crow, and more recently, King in the North, all while being known as a bastard.

His status as a bastard does not fully exclude him from inheriting titles or lands, but it certainly complicates the process. Until his parentage becomes common knowledge, it is easier to imagine Jon following Tyrion's advice and carrying this title as a symbol of his power and influence.

The Revelation of Lineage

Recently, Jon Snow's true parentage has been revealed. The revelation that Lyanna Stark, not Edward Stark, mothered him has been a crucial turning point in Westerosi politics. Additionally, it has been established that Jon is a Targaryen, the son of Rhaegar Targaryan and Lyanna Stark. This dual heritage could significantly alter the landscape of the Seven Kingdoms.

Despite this revelation, Jon has not been acclaimed as a member of the Stark family. He is still considered a bastard, even with his Stark identity. This status has implications for his title and legitimacy within the House of Stark, where Sansa is recognized as the Lady of Winterfell and the official Stark of Winterfell.

Legitimization Through the Law

The process of legitimation in A Song of Ice and Fire is complex. Only the High Septon or a royal decree can fully legitimize a bastard. With public declaration, Jon Snow could technically declare himself Jon Stark, and this decision might be widely accepted, especially given his upbringing and the support of Ned Stark. However, the legal process would still need to be followed for full legitimacy.

Technically, Jon Snow could claim legitimacy if he were to issue a public declaration. This decision could be bolstered by the fact that he was raised in Winterfell, where Ned Stark adopted him as his own son. This could give Jon's claim precedents over Sansa's, but not Bran's.

However, other scenarios could also come into play. If the letter legitimizing Jon as the heir to Winterfell had reached Howland Reed at Greywater Watch, he could have publicly declared Jon's legitimacy, securing his claim to the North. Alternatively, Jon could out himself as a member of the Blackfyre line, challenging Cersei and Dany's claims to the Iron Throne. His Targaryen heritage makes him a viable contender, especially if he is seen as a strong male heir amidst the struggles of maintaining a female claim.

Implications of Legitimization

The legitimacy of Jon Snow has significant implications for the political landscape of Westeros. If he were to be fully legitimized, it would not only solidify his claim to the North but also potentially enhance his standing in the eyes of the Targaryen supporters. However, the process of legitimation is fraught with challenges and risks. It requires a strategic political move, whether through legal means or public declaration.

Additionally, as a highborn bastard, Jon Snow benefits from the allowances afforded to such individuals. In the absence of legitimate male heirs, highborn bastards often receive special treatment. This could work in his favor, especially in the context of political negotiations and alliances.

However, the revelation of his Targaryen heritage and his subsequent legitimation as a Starkchamber would make Jon Snow a more formidable and complex character, blending the somber and noble Stark lineage with the fiery Targaryen ambition. This duality could bring both opportunities and conflicts, highlighting the intricate political web of Westeros.

Conclusion

Jon Snow's potential legitimation is a critical aspect of his role in the ongoing saga of Westeros. Whether through legal means, public declaration, or strategic political maneuvering, the path to full legitimacy remains open, though fraught with challenges. The decision he makes will undoubtedly shape the future of the North and the broader political landscape of the Seven Kingdoms.