Culture Compass

Location:HOME > Culture > content

Culture

Non-Citizens and Head of State: Unique Cases Around the World

January 06, 2025Culture1659
Introduction While citizenship often determines political ro

Introduction

While citizenship often determines political roles within countries, there are unique scenarios where a non-citizen can ascend to the highest positions of power. This article explores the surprising cases where foreign individuals can become the head of state, specifically focusing on the United Kingdom, Andorra, and the United States.

United Kingdom

The United Kingdom provides a unique scenario for a non-citizen to potentially become the Prime Minister, the head of its government. Technically, the only requirement for the Prime Minister is being the leader of the party or coalition with the most seats in Parliament, and ideally, being an elected Member of Parliament (MP).

To be an MP, you must meet the following criteria:

Be at least 18 years old Be a British citizen, a citizen of the Republic of Ireland, a Commonwealth citizen who does not require leave to enter or remain in the UK, or have indefinite leave to remain in the UK

Therefore, theoretically, a non-citizen of British or any Commonwealth origin who is a naturalized British citizen and subsequently wins a parliamentary election could become the Prime Minister.

Andorra

Andorra stands out with its unique political structure. It has two heads of state known as "princes." One prince is the Bishop of La Seu d'Urgell, a Spanish town, and the other is the president of France. The office of the French president was inherited from the French monarchy when France became a republic.

Becoming the president of France requires French citizenship, but under this dual monarchy system, the French president automatically makes a foreign individual a prince of Andorra. This makes Andorra unique in that one of its princes must be a citizen of a foreign country.

United States

The United States has stringent requirements for its president, requiring a "natural born citizen." However, the specifics of what constitutes a "natural born citizen" are debated. Unlike the United Kingdom, where citizenship can be acquired even if you are not a native-born citizen, the US requirement is more defined.

Typically, a "natural born citizen" is a person who is a citizen from birth, whether they are born in the United States or to citizen parents abroad.

Student Council Elections

Interestingly, non-citizens can hold positions of leadership even at a younger age. In the United States, international students who are resident aliens and attending school can be elected to student council positions up to and including student body president. This demonstrates the acceptance of non-citizens in positions of student leadership, echoing the broader theme of non-citizen leadership in elected roles.

Conclusion

While citizenship is generally a prerequisite for high-ranking political positions, the United Kingdom, Andorra, and the United States offer unique exceptions. These cases highlight the flexibility and varying nature of leadership roles in different countries, challenging the preconception that only citizens can lead. As global interactions continue to evolve, such scenarios may become more commonplace, further blurring the lines between national and non-national leadership.