The Resilient Catholic Church: Insights into Its Durability Compared to Mainline Protestantism

As a person of faith, I can't say that I am entirely enthused by the question of why the decline of the Catholic Church in the West has been much slower compared to mainline Protestantism. It is analogous to asking, 'What is so noteworthy about the resilience of the Catholic Church in the face of such a decline?' The distinguishing characteristics that separate mainline denominations from the Catholic Church can provide valuable clues and insights.

Why Mainline Churches Have Failed to Matter Anymore

Many mainline Protestants, in their zeal for all-inclusivity, may inadvertently be demonstrating why their own congregations have failed to matter anymore. If other religions are able to meet God where their members are, then why should one continue going to a local mainline church? Why bother when one can worship God through music on their mobile devices and listen to sermons or podcasts from other millennials who demonstrate a more modern approach?

This is not unlike the demise of Christian Contemporary Music, where the emergence of bands crossing over to secular radio saw the exodus of many. As Amy Grant and Switchfoot showed, why write songs for a limited market when the general market already has the ears?

The Role of Scientific Understanding and Biblical Interpretation

A notable distinction between the Catholic Church and many mainline Protestant churches lies in their handling of tough biblical questions, such as homosexuality and the creation story. The Catholic Church actually has a healthy relationship with science, despite any Galileo horror stories one may hear. Many Protestant churches, however, tend to struggle with this balance.

In my view, the Catholic faith has reached out to people with same-sex attraction with far more grace than many Protestant counterparts. This is a difficult issue, but the Catholic Church has demonstrated a deeper understanding and compassion for those affected by it.

The Impact of Church Scandals

A note should be made about the Catholic Church scandals that came to light in Boston and later made into an Academy Award-winning film. The actions of errant bishops and cardinals that allowed predators to continue their abuse on innocents were one of the most evil crimes of our time. However, it is noteworthy that the hierarchical structure of the Catholic Church has been able to make significant strides in safeguarding its members.

Since these incidents, detailed safeguards have been put in place that have, so far, done the job. It is also important to recognize that many social groups, including different denominations, religions, and secular groups, have found themselves in similar hot water. The Catholic Church's hierarchical structure, when used appropriately, was able to address and curtail these activities. This structure has also allowed the laity to play a role in reporting warning signs and taking necessary actions.

The Importance of Grace and Institutional Consistency

The best answer, of course, is grace. We do not deserve to continue as a single unit, and there have been many instances throughout history where the Catholic Church has been as corrupt as it is. Yet, we believe there is a supernatural hand that has kept this structure from toppling entirely.

The Catholic Church still has the Body of Christ, the graces from the personal Pentecost, the prayers of Mary and the saints, and centuries of wisdom from its most theologically minded geniuses, such as Augustine, Aquinas, Chesterton, Pope John Paul II, and many others.

Comparatively, many mainline denominations are rooted in the vision and preaching of single individuals, such as Luther, Calvin, Edwards, Wesley, Finney, Tozer, and Schaeffer, but these churches have often seen inconsistencies in their teachings over the centuries.

The strength of the Catholic Church lies in its documents, such as the Catechism, encyclicals, and the documents of Vatican II. These documents provide a clear thread that links doctrines throughout history, ensuring consistency and continuity in the faith.

While there are many failings of the Catholic Church, its resilience and ability to maintain institutional integrity are significant factors in its continued relevance and strength.