Understanding Legal and Cultural Prohibited Practices: Polygamy vs. Polyamory in the Mormon Community

The Differences in Legal and Cultural Prohibited Practices: Polygamy vs. Polyamory in the Mormon Community

Introduction

Polygamy and polyamory, while both involving multiple partners, often face different legal and cultural interpretations and challenges. This essay delves into the discrepancies between these practices, particularly within the Mormon community, and the reasons behind the legal stance against polygamy but the acceptance or nonchalance towards polyamory.

Legal Status of Polyamory and Polygamy

The legal definition and acceptance of polygamy and polyamory vary significantly based on jurisdiction and cultural context. Polyamory, generally defined as a relationship with more than two individuals, is not illegal in most countries, whereas polygamy is often viewed with suspicion and criminalized. This essay focuses on the Mormon community, where these practices are particularly relevant.

Understanding the Mormon Perspective

Mormon Doctrine and Monogamy

The doctrine of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (often referred to as the Mormon Church) holds that monogamy is the standard practice, unless specially commanded by the Lord. However, the Church officially ended the practice of polygamy in 1890 and no new polygamous marriages have been allowed since. Despite this, the Church's stance on polygamy remains firm, and those found practicing it today are excommunicated.

Prevalence and Preferences

While the Church's practices may suggest otherwise, the vast majority of its members prefer monogamy, with only a small percentage (approximately 10%) of early members participating in polygamous relationships. Traditions and cultural shifts have led to a significant shift towards monogamy since the early days of the Church.

Church Teachings on Sexual Activity

The Church also enforces a strict policy prohibiting any sexual activity outside of marriage, further emphasizing its stance against polyamory. This strict adherence to monogamous marriage is a core tenet of their religious doctrine, aligning with broader societal norms.

Historical and Cultural Context

Historical Persecution and Outlawing of Polygamy

The outlawing of polygamy in the United States can be traced back to historical persecution experienced by the Church. In its early days, the Church faced intense opposition and hostility, leading to several conflicts and ultimately the expulsion from the United States. The federal government, influenced by puritan ideals and anti-Mormon sentiments, made polygamy illegal as a means of harassing the Church.

Current Legal Landscape

Today, changing laws regarding polygamy would require significant political will and support, which is currently absent. In many states, voting for such changes could be seen as political suicide. The irony is that if laws were to change, it would likely be driven by the far left rather than the Mormon Church itself, which has no fervent desire to resume polygamy.

Conclusion

While polygamy and polyamory both involve multiple partners, the legal and cultural contexts in which they operate differ significantly. The Mormon community's stance on these practices highlights the complex interplay between religious doctrine, historical context, and legal systems. Understanding these nuances is crucial for anyone seeking to grasp the complexities of these social phenomena.

Keywords: polyamory, polygamy, Mormon Church, legal status, religious doctrines