Why Do Italians Speak Loudly in Public? Unveiling the Cultural Tradition and Perception

While sitting on a quiet balcony in Alonissos at 22:00, I couldn't help but notice an Italian man on his phone bellowing like a deranged person. This observation led me to reflect on the behavior of Italians and how they communicate in public spaces. This habit of speaking loudly isn't unique to Italians; it's prevalent throughout the Mediterranean region, including Spain. However, the reasons behind this behavior are intriguing and deeply rooted in cultural tradition.

Historical Context and Outdoor Social Life

The habit of speaking loudly in public can be traced back to the social and cultural practices of the Mediterranean region. Social life, especially in markets and squares, has always been a primary setting for interaction. Due to favorable weather conditions, family life was often conducted outdoors as well. This culminated in a cultural expectation to communicate clearly and confidently, even outdoors. Yet, as I observed, the behavior differs significantly in regions with shorter fine seasons, confirming my hypothesis.

Perception and Contrast with Other Cultures

Speaking loudly is often viewed as a sign of poor upbringing or as simply part of the Italian character. However, it's important to note that this stereotype may be misguided. In reality, Italians generally speak loudly when there is a need, just as everyone else does. In Hollywood movies, Italians are often portrayed speaking loudly and boisterously, but this is a oversimplification of their cultural norms.

Cultural Tradition and Communication Style

In Italian culture, speaking loudly is rooted in historical traditions and the communication style of the ancient Romans. The Ars Loquendi, the art of speaking, is a concept that has been instilled since childhood. Italians take pride in speaking clearly, confidently, and expressively, making each syllable count. On the other hand, they are also trained in tolerantia et magnanimitas, which means tolerance and magnanimity when speaking to "Barbarians," or people from abroad who are used to speaking unclearly.

Discipline and Respect in Public Spaces

Contrary to popular belief, Italians are not constantly speaking loudly in public and especially in public spaces. The culture actually foresees speaking softly in these environments. Americans, for example, are often perceived as speaking more loudly and less disciplined. This cultural expectation encourages everyone to maintain respect and avoid judging others, regardless of their speaking volume.

Conclusion

The behavior of Italians speaking loudly in public is a complex cultural phenomenon rooted in historical and social traditions. While stereotypes may persist, it's important to understand the cultural context and the reasons behind this behavior. Italians speak loudly when necessary, just as any other culture does, but the significance of speaking clearly and expressively is deeply ingrained in their cultural identity.